Automated Component Improvement

Changes

• Rewrote description with three <example> blocks following llm-architect format, covering: task-specific model selection, benchmark design from scratch, and post-deployment regression testing — each with Context:, user:, assistant:, and <commentary> explaining delegation boundaries vs llm-architect and prompt-engineer
• Added Standard Frameworks & Tools section with a Markdown table covering HELM, EleutherAI lm-evaluation-harness, DeepEval, RAGAS, Promptfoo, and Chatbot Arena with "Best For / When to Use" guidance
• Updated Model Categories to tier-based language (Haiku/Sonnet/Opus) and current model names (GPT-4o, GPT-4o-mini, Gemini 1.5/2.0, Llama 3, Mistral, Qwen); removed deprecated GPT-3.5 and Gemini Pro/Ultra references; added note to verify current model IDs
• Added model: sonnet to YAML frontmatter; expanded tools to Read, Write, Edit, Bash, Glob, Grep, WebSearch
• Replaced skeletal evaluate_code_model Python stub with Statistical Requirements section: minimum sample sizes, 95% CI reporting, effect size (Cohen's d/kappa), inter-rater reliability threshold (kappa > 0.8), Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons, paired test guidance
• Added Integration with Other Agents table mapping handoffs to llm-architect, prompt-engineer, and ai-ethics-advisor
• Added Step 6: Post-Deployment Monitoring covering drift detection, re-evaluation triggers, alerting thresholds, and tools (Arize Phoenix, LangSmith, Promptfoo CI)
• Removed 🎯 emoji from output template header

Research Summary

The component had solid coverage of evaluation dimensions and cost analysis but lacked the <example>-block description format used by peer agents, referenced outdated model names, contained a skeletal Python stub with no implementation value, and had no statistical rigor guidance, no framework recommendations, and no post-deployment monitoring step. All seven prioritized improvements from the research report have been applied.

Validation

• component-reviewer: PASSED
  • Valid YAML frontmatter with all required fields (name, description, model, tools)
  • kebab-case naming consistent with filename
  • No hardcoded secrets or API keys
  • No absolute paths
  • File in correct category directory (ai-specialists)
  • No emoji in output template

Automated review cycle by Component Improvement Loop

Summary by cubic

Modernizes the model-evaluator with current model taxonomy, concrete examples, statistical standards, and monitoring to make evaluations reliable end to end. Affects components (cli-tool/components/).

• New Features
  • Rewrote the description with three blocks and clear handoffs to llm-architect, prompt-engineer, and ai-ethics-advisor.
  • Added frameworks and tooling guidance (HELM, lm-evaluation-harness, DeepEval, RAGAS, Promptfoo, Chatbot Arena) and post-deploy monitoring (drift alerts via Arize Phoenix, LangSmith, Promptfoo CI).
  • Updated model taxonomy and frontmatter (model: sonnet; tools expanded to Read, Write, Edit, Bash, Glob, Grep, WebSearch); removed deprecated refs and emoji.
  • Replaced the code stub with statistical requirements (min samples, 95% CI, effect sizes, inter-rater reliability, multiple-comparison control). No new components; catalog (docs/components.json) unchanged; no new env vars or secrets.

^{Written for commit 6bea3e8. Summary will update on new commits.}